|
Vidas: Hi guys, this is Vidas.
Ausra: And Ausra. V: Let’s start episode 394 of Secrets of Organ Playing Podcast. This question was sent by Don and he writes: “Hello Vidas, Would you please provide your ideas on how to "identify a piece of organ literature by level of difficulty" and provide actual titles of pieces so that we, as organists, can make choices on our own when we want to study a new piece of literature. Thank You, Don” V: What do you think Ausra, do you think it is easy to identify levels of difficulty? A: Well I think that’s a nice question. You could write a book about it because it’s sort of what Don wants that you would provide a list of pieces with level marks on them and it takes actually a lot of time. V: Luckily we have American Guild of Organists (AGO) and if you go to their web site https://www.agohq.org and click on EDUCATION and then click on Educational Resources there you have interesting things. Basically these are lists of all organ compositions that for example Jehan Alain created, Johann Sebastian Bach, Guy Bovet, Maurice Durufle, and others but what I found very interesting is Graded Repertoire Documents and there you have of course not many but a few of them; Bach, Langlais, Messiaen, Rorem, and German music after Bach meaning romantic and classical composers too. For example if we click on Bach and you have this possibility to see a document created by Delbert Disselhorst, who was the professor of our professor Pamela Ruiter-Feenstra at Eastern Michigan University and there he has a list of most or all of Bach’s works arranged into four levels. So for example in level one you have Neumeister Chorales, of course Eight Little Preludes and Fugues, of course today it is thought that a student of Bach created these, not Bach himself, Pedal Exercitium, Pastorale, Alla Breve, Canzona, those are level one pieces. But of course they are not suitable for beginners, right Ausra? A: Yes. V: Too difficult for beginners. Beginners can only play something like a minuet when both voices move very slowly. What do you think about the smallest rhythmical value in beginner level pieces. A: I think it might be too hard for some people truly. V: Quarter-note, occasional eighth notes but with Bach you already have sixteenth notes and we advise to start with something easier before Bach and less voices than normally four. Basically two voices is the best. A: Yes but sometimes not the number of voices gives difficulty too because there might be some really demanding pieces even written in two voices for example duets for the third part of Clavierubung. I wouldn’t see these pieces for beginners even though they only have two voices. V: Let’s see if they have those here in the list in which case they should be somewhere towards the end. Clavierubung III is in the fourth level, in the last level but he writes “Many of the manualiter settings may be studied earlier…”, right? So duets could be studied earlier but certainly not at the beginning. A: Yes, but not number one. V: So Don and others were wondering about grading their organ pieces should understand one thing that real composers created music not necessarily for pedagogical intent and even if they did in those days, 200 years ago, the pedagogical aspect was different than today. The master would write something to you and the student would play it no matter what and today the student would say “No, no, no, it’s too difficult” and the master would say “Oh you poor baby.” A: That’s right, everything has changed. V: So yes, for level one obviously we need two voices and very simple rhythms, then you can either add one more voice and still keep simple rhythms or you can do two voices but with more advanced rhythms like sixteenth notes. A: True, but again three voices not always will mean the easy composition as we have example by J.S. Bach, his trio sonatas, they are one of the most demanding pieces in the organ repertoire and they have only three voices. V: I would find this categorization quite helpful for example in terms of how many voices there are one, two, three, four, or more, we have five voices, sometimes even six in the organ repertoire. A: Sure, double pedal. V: Right. Imagine six levels and then in each level we could have sub-levels in terms of rhythmical difficulties. What’s the smallest rhythmical unit, most commonly used note. If you sometimes see sixteenth notes it doesn’t mean that the entire composition is moving in sixteenth notes, just occasionally but maybe the most common rhythmical value is in eighth notes so that would mean probably a second level with eighth notes and the first level would be with quarter notes for me. A: But still you always need to look at the tempo, what tempo the piece is written in because sometimes you could have as small note values as thirty-second for example but it still might be not as hard as it looks on the paper when it is all black because the tempo might be really slow as happens in many ornamented chorales. V: Right. All those things you have to keep in mind while selecting your new organ piece. A: And of course look at the pedal part because it still for many people pedal gives most of the trouble. V: Right. And to be considered level one probably pedal needs to move slower than the hands. A: Sure, sure, probably in half notes. V: Half notes, exactly not in quarter notes. A: Yes. V: And in level two probably in quarter notes, and level three eighth notes and maybe triplets if that’s another disposition of rhythms and meters. So I guess you can get the idea of how to calculate the difficulty of the piece that you are about to study and your own level too. A: And you also need to keep in mind the coordination problems too because for many beginners it’s easier to play on one manual and on the pedal than for example on two different manuals at the same time and the pedal. This also might make the piece more difficult or more easy or when you have to switch manuals a lot during the performance. V: Then we didn’t mention the keys and the chromaticisms. A: Sure because the more accidentals a piece has the harder it is to learn to read music. V: The same piece in C Major would have lower level of difficulty than the same piece with four sharps for example. Umm-hmm. OK guys, we hope this was useful to you. Please send us your wonderful questions and remember when you practice… A: Miracles happen. Last Tuesday it was supposed to be my regular practice at my church. My practice usually consists of pieces I'm currently working on, improvisation and sight-reading.
Some things got in the way and I had to leave before I had time to sight-read anything that day. Luckily, in the afternoon during Unda Maris organ studio rehearsal, my student Mindaugas Dulkys was playing Voluntary in D Major No. 6, Op. 6 by John Stanley (1712-1786) from England. I wanted to show him how it's done and figured I could play it in a slow practice tempo. Not only I wanted to help him, I thought, but I also wanted to sight-read something that day. Luckily, I had a video camera with me and recorded everything from the high angle so that my fingers were clearly visible as I usually do when I sight-read. Of course, I had an idea to turn it into a practice score to help other students as well. Thanks to Mindaugas Dulkys for his meticulous transcription of the fingering from my slow motion video into original edition from 1752. Intermediate level. Manuals only. PDF score. 3 pages. 4 movements: Adagio-Andante-Adagio-Allegro Moderato 50% discount is valid until February 23. Check it out here This score is free for Total Organist students. Would you like to learn J.S. Bach's Kyrie, Gott Heiliger Geist, BWV 671 from the Clavierubung III? If so, my new PDF score with complete early fingering and pedaling will save you many hours and set you on the path of success to achieve the ideal articulate legato touch naturally, almost without thinking.
Since this is a 5-voice chorale prelude for Organo Pleno registration, for most of the time, the right hand plays two voices and the left hand also has two-part texture. The pedals have a chorale Cantus firmus in augmentation (long note values). If you liked Kyrie, Gott Vater in Ewigkeit, BWV 669, Christe, aller Welt Trost, BWV 670, Allein Gott, BWV 676 or Dies sind die heilgen zehn Gebot, BWV 678 I'm sure you'll enjoy this piece too. Thanks to Mary for her meticulous transcription from my slow motion video! Advanced level. 4 pages. 50% discount is valid until February 21. Check it out here This score is free for Total Organist students. If you liked my PDF score of Leon Boellmann's Toccata or Introduction-Choral from Suite Gothique, Op. 25, I'm sure you will enjoy his sweet Priere a Notre Dame.
Thanks to Jeremy Owens for his meticulous transcription of fingering from the slow motion video. Intermediate level. PDF score. 4 pages. Check it out here 50% discount is valid until February 12. This score is free for Total Organist students. These delightful variations of Balleto del Granduca originally were attributed to Jan Pieterszoon Sweelinck but recent scholarship points to Samuel Scheidt as a composer.
I have created this score with the hope that it will help my students who love early music to recreate articulate legato style automatically, almost without thinking. Thanks to David Koch for his meticulous transcription of fingering from the slow motion videos. Intermediate level. Manuals only. PDF score. 3 pages. Check it out here 50% discount is valid until February 8. This score is free for Total Organist students. AVA149: Do You Have A Piece Of Similar Difficulty To Handel's Largo With Fingering And Pedaling?2/3/2018 Vidas: Hi guys, this is Vidas.
Ausra: And Ausra. Vidas: Let’s start Episode 149 of #AskVidasAndAusra podcast. And this question was sent by David. He writes: Hello Vidas, I am making progress slowly on Largo from Xerxes. I'm at the point that I would like to also start working on another piece as I finish up Largo. Do you have a piece of similar difficulty with modern fingering and pedaling that you could recommend for me? Also congratulations on 6 years of Secrets of Organ Playing! This is an excellent service and you and Ausra are going a great job! David So this is really nice, that people value our work, right Ausra? Ausra: Yes, it’s always nice to know that somebody appreciates your work. Vidas: So, talking about this question that David asks...he needs help in choosing a similar piece to Largo by Handel, right? Ausra: Yes. Vidas: Do you think that it should be a Baroque composition or a Romantic or modern piece, according to him? Ausra: It depends on what he likes. Probably, maybe, another Baroque piece. What do you think about it? Vidas: He did mention that he needs modern fingering and pedaling. But what he means by this, I don’t know. It wouldn’t hurt to play more Baroque pieces, right? Ausra: Sure. Vidas: Do you think we could recommend something created by Krebs, for example? Right, from his Clavierübung Chorale Preludes, like Allein Gott, or Jesu meine Freude? Ausra: Don’t you think this would be too hard, compared to Handel? Vidas: Jesu meine Freude? Is it too difficult, you think? Ausra: Well, yes, you have to have quite good manual technique. Vidas: What’s so problematic about Jesu meine Freude? Sixteenth note runs, or…? Ausra: Well, yes! Vidas: Anything else? Ausra: You would need to have much better technique already, compared to that aria of Handel. Don’t you think so? Don’t you agree? Vidas: And it doesn’t have pedals. So maybe he needs pedals, right? Do you think we could recommend a piece by Johann Sebastian Bach, like chorale preludes or something? Ausra: Well, of course. Vidas: What would you suggest? Ausra: Are you thinking about Chorale Preludes, or about free pieces? Vidas: Both. Let’s say both. And first of all, let’s say a free piece, like 3 or 4 pages long, maybe. Ausra: Well, this could be one of the Eight Little Preludes, like g minor, for example. Vidas: It would seem like it would be a good choice, g minor, because the prelude is rather slow, and the pedal work is not too complex, and the texture is very chordal; but then the problem is with the fugue, right? Ausra: Yes, the fugue is much harder than the prelude. Vidas: What is complicated about the fugue, Ausra? Ausra: Because you have to master all those notes that are equally important; and already the pedals are quite complicated. Vidas: Do you think that David could start on the pedal part right away, instead of playing from the beginning? Ausra: Of course. You always need to learn the harder spots first. Vidas: What else would you recommend that he could play, like maybe a Chorale Prelude, three or four parts…? Ausra: Maybe some Preludes from the Orgelbüchlein, or from the Notebook of Anna Magdalena Bach. Vidas: Mhmm. Ausra: Or… Vidas: Dances? Ausra: Yes. Vidas: Dances should definitely be doable. And from Orgelbüchlein, things like Ich ruf’ zu dir. Ausra: Yes, because it’s a slow tempo, yes. Vidas: Or even maybe O mensch bewein, but… Ausra: Well, that cantus firmus is so ornamented, it’s not that easy to play. I think Ich ruf’ zu dir is easier. You could even decipher the chords in this piece. Vidas: Easier. So maybe O Mensch bewein could be for later. Ausra: Sure. Vidas: But it’s very beautiful. Ausra: Yes, it’s very beautiful. Vidas: One of the most beautiful pieces from the Baroque period. Ausra: I agree. Vidas: Excellent. Could we recommend something for David and people like David in that level--maybe from the Romantic period? Ausra: Of course, there’s a lot of music you can play from the Romantic period. Vidas: Maybe...Let’s say, some French music--like, Vierne wrote this beautiful Berceuse, remember? Ausra: Yes, it’s very nice, and not that hard. Vidas: It could be played with pedals or without pedals. Ausra: Both ways, I believe. Vidas: Both ways. And it’s worth trying. Ausra: Yes, and there’s also that, you know, collection of so-called L’Organiste by Cesar Franck, which is also doable and not that hard. Vidas: Mhm. Ausra: And you can also play it without pedals, because it’s intended to play on the… Vidas: Harmonium? Ausra: Harmonium, yes. Vidas: Good. I think people could find a lot of suitable material in this collection, too. And remember, you have to use modern fingering and pedaling, right? We haven’t, I think, prepared any scores by Franck yet. But we did write down fingering and pedaling for Berceuse by Vierne, Allegretto by Vierne, but it’s a little more complex. But not too much. And then, I think, Meditation by Vierne is also a similar slow motion, meditative piece. That could be possible. What else? Or is it enough for starters? Ausra: I think it should be enough for starters. Vidas: Mhm. It’s best, guys, to try just a few pieces, and master them to the best of your ability--to spend some time, right? Right, Ausra? Ausra: That’s true. Don’t practice too many pieces at once, because then your progress will be very slow. Vidas: Unless you want to sightread things, like… Ausra: Sure. Vidas: Do you recommend sightreading, Ausra? Regularly? Ausra: Yes, it’s always beneficial to sightread things. Vidas: How much time should you spend, or could you spend, every day? Ausra: Well, I would say at least 10 minutes. Vidas: So, do you think that in 10 minutes usually in a slow tempo, people could play through maybe a couple of pages, right? Ausra: Well, it depends on how long your pages are. Vidas: Mhmm. Ausra: And how advanced you are. Vidas: Maybe some people could play 5 pages in that tempo, right? Ausra: Yes, yes. Vidas: So, a piece or two, right? Generally not too long. So, choose your favorite collection that you love, and of course you will be on your way to mastering sightreading as well! It’s very beneficial in the long run. Anything else, Ausra, you could recommend? Ausra: Well, just keep practicing every day. Vidas: Yes. Try not to skip a practice. On your calendar, you could mark X, X, X, on each day; that will be a wonderful feeling after one month or two months or three months. Thanks, guys, for listening, and applying our advice in your practice. This is really fascinating for us, to help you grow. And send us more of your questions, right Ausra? Ausra: Yes, we are waiting. Vidas: And remember, when you practice… Ausra: Miracles happen. Would you like to learn Da Pacem, Domine, in diebus nostris by the great Jan Pieterszoon Sweelinck (1562-1621)?
If so, this score is for you because it will save you many hours of frustration. I have created early fingering for every single note which will allow you to achieve articulate legato automatically, almost without thinking. This set consists of 4 variations (manualiter only, no pedals): Variation 1: Bicinium with the chorale melody (cantus firmus) in the soprano Variation 2: Trio with the chorale melody in the tenor Variation 3: Quartet with the chorale melody in the alto Variation 4: Quartet with the chorale melody in the bass Note that these four settings are perfect example for anybody wants to creatively play hymn accompaniments. You too, can create duets, trios, and quartets from any hymn tune and place the melody in ANY voice. Thanks to Alan who meticulously transcribed the fingering from my videos. 50% discount is valid until February 5. Check out this score here Intermediate level. PDF score (4 pages). This score is free for Total Organist students. SOP Podcast #123: Luca Massaglia on acoustics, expanding your repertoire and giving presents12/3/2017 Welcome to Secrets of Organ Playing Podcast #123!
Listen to the conversation
In this conversation, Luca shares his insights about his interest in Jazz, the modes of Messiaen, harmony, music of Jehan Alain. He also recounts his experiences from his concert tours in Russia where big audiences are attending organ concerts whereas in Western Europe not so many anymore are interested in this art. We also talk about the opera influences on Italian organ music, Renaissance music, acoustics, expanding your repertoire and giving musical presents. You can find out more about Luca's activities at www.lucamassaglia.com. Enjoy and share your comments below. And don't forget to help spread the word about the SOP Podcast by sharing it with your organist friends. If you like it, feel free to subscribe to our channel on Musicoin. By the way, you can upload your own recordings to YOUR channel to maximize revenue. If you have some audio recordings of your organ performances, you can do the same. Feel free to use my invitation link to join Musicoin: https://musicoin.org/accept/MUSICa45e5f26ede2be5dd4411747 Thanks for caring. Listen to the conversation Relevant links: www.lucamassaglia.com Luca Massaglia's channel on YouTube At the end of last summer the world-famous Dutch organist Pieter van Dijk came to Vilnius, Lithuania for a few days to give master-classes on early music. As part of this event he also played an hour-long recital at the Cathedral.
One of the pieces that really stood out was J.S. Bach's fugue in C minor on the theme of Legrenzi, BWV 574. Believe it or not I've never played nor heard this beautiful fugue before. Van Dijk's playing was so inspiring and so rhythmically strong that the pulse could be heard even in the most romantic compositions from that day's repertoire. It's a complex double fugue - the second theme enters in the middle of page 2. It also has fascinating canonic stretto entrances which will not be very easy to learn yet I'm sure lovers of fugue genre will find them amazing. The ending of the fugue is particularly worth mentioning. At the end of page 6 the piece sort of ends with a strong authentic cadence but Bach decided to compose one more page with an extended virtuoso plagal cadence - basically a long excursion into the subdominant key of F minor which is also extended by the authentic cadence. Contrary to basic logic, please make sure you hold the last chord extremely short. This will help you make a strong impact on your listeners (just like Pieter van Dijk made on me). Ever since this recital, the fugue on the theme of Legrenzi haunted me wherever I went so that I decided to create a PDF practice score for you. I hope you'll enjoy playing from my score (7 pages) with complete fingering and pedaling which will save you many hours and set you on the efficient path of mastering it. Let me know how your practice goes. 50 % discount is valid until November 15. This score is free for Total Organist students. A few days ago I have received a request from Christian-Angel to provide a score of BWV 579 with fingering and pedaling. That's Johann Sebastian Bach's Fugue in B minor on the Theme by Corelli.
Today I finally finished this project which any of our students can now take advantage of. It will save you many hours of struggle and help you to master this beautiful fugue easier and quicker. It's a PDF score with 5 pages. A few tips on learning this piece: For Christian-Angel the most difficult part is the final Stretto - the last 3 systems. This is not surprising because in any Stretto composer develops the theme canonically. This means that a few voices have the same melody played but not at the same time - the parts enter before the previous one has finished. In this fugue it's so important to practice ALL 15 combinations separately: S, A, T, B, SA, ST, SB, AT, AB, TB, SAT, SAB, STB, ATB and SATB. Make sure you don't skip any of the steps and try not to rush - extremely slow tempo works best for practice purposes. Don't forget that you don't have to work on the fugue on its entirety, practice of small episodes of about 1 line works best. Start and finish each episode on the downbeat. This helps to connect the fragments between themselves. In my experience, I had to repeat each step at least 3 times without mistakes in a row before I was ready to go on to the next combination. And if you apply my fingering, you will achieve articulate legato naturally, almost without thinking. 50 % discount is valid until November 15. Enjoy and let me know how your practice goes. This score is free for Total Organist students. |
DON'T MISS A THING! FREE UPDATES BY EMAIL.Thank you!You have successfully joined our subscriber list. Photo by Edgaras Kurauskas
Authors
Drs. Vidas Pinkevicius and Ausra Motuzaite-Pinkeviciene Organists of Vilnius University , creators of Secrets of Organ Playing. Our Hauptwerk Setup:
Don't have an organ at home? No problem - print out our paper organ manuals and pedals and start practicing today!
Categories
All
Archives
October 2026
|


RSS Feed